The Fourth Trimester – AKA: Why Your Newborn is Only Happy in Your Arms.
- “My baby is only happy in my arms, the minute I put her down she cries”
- “He sleeps really well but only when he’s laying on my chest, he hates his moses basket”
- “She cries every time we lay her on her play mat”
- “He hates going in his pram, he cries the second we put him in it”.
How many times have you heard these comments from new parents? How many times have you said them yourself?
I’ve lost count of the amount of times I have been asked these questions! What amazes me though is that society in general doesn’t get it, they don’t get why so many babies need to be held by us to settle and what perplexes me even more is that we do spend so long trying to put them down!

We spend more than time though, the ‘putting babies down’ industry is worth millions, rocking cribs, battery swings, vibrating chairs, heartbeat teddies and the list goes on………………having been a first time parent who bought all four of the items listed above I am embarrased to admit now it honestly didn’t enter into my head that perhaps the answer was to *not* put my baby down and I certainly didn’t consider why these things might help. It took me a long time to understand and empathise with my baby, to see the world through his eyes so to speak.
“Empathy: the intellectual identification with or vicarious experiencing ofthe feelings, thoughts, or attitudes of another.”
To empathise with our newborns feelings we need to put ourselves in their place, to imagine experiencing their world – but which world? The world they have spent most of their life in, their ‘womb world’ or the world they are in now – our world. To fully understand we must appreciate the enormous transition they have made – a concept known to many as ‘The Fourth Trimester’ -some make the womb to world transition easily, others less so and it is this latter group in particular “the clingy babies” we can learn so much from through this concept.
“Birth suddenly disrupts this organization. During the month following birth, baby tries to regain his sense of organization and fit into life outside the womb. Birth and adaptation to postnatal life bring out the temperament of the baby, so for the first time he must do something to have his needs met. He is forced to act, to “behave.” If hungry, cold, or startled, he cries. He must make an effort to get the things he needs from his caregiving environment. If his needs are simple and he can get what he wants easily, he’s labeled an “easy baby”; if he does not adapt readily, he is labeled “difficult.”” – Dr. William Sears.
So lets quickly compare the two different ‘worlds’ your baby has lived in:

Pretty different huh? On top of this the big thing to understand is that in utero the baby’s world was constant, each day was the same, the stimulation didn’t change, but now they are born each day is different – ever changing, ever stimulating!
You’ll find a more in-depth discussion on this idea and much more in my BabyCalm Book – available from Amazon in the UK or with worldwide free delivery from The Book Depository if you live elsewhere in the world.

The concept of the fourth trimester helps us to understand the transition a newborn must make over their first few weeks earthside and once we understand we find so many ways we can help – but to me the most important facet of the fourth trimester is parental understanding and empathy, once that exists everything else will flow naturally.
Here are some common newborn calming techniques that tend to work quite well, but remember each and every baby is different, if you don’t already know, you will soon learn what your baby likes best and that’s what matters, that it is unique to *your* baby. Prescriptive ‘do this/don’t do this’ baby calming lists don’t help anybody – because they forget they are dealing with individuals – both parents and babies! Some things on this list will be inappropriate for you and your baby, some simply won’t work, some you won’t like – and that’s OK! because really it isn’t about these tips it’s about you and your baby getting to know each other!
Movement
The womb is a constantly moving space, Braxton Hicks would squeeze your baby at the end of pregnancy and each time you moves your baby was wobbled around inside. Imagine how walking upstairs feels for a baby in utero! Babies tend to love movement but so often we put them down somewhere completely still. You could try dancing, swaying from side to side, going for an exaggerated quick walk or bumpy car ride.
Swaddling
Imagine how snug your baby was at the very end of your pregnancy inside of you – now imagine how strange it must feel to them after they have been born and have so much space around them! The absolutely best thing you can do is to envelop your baby in your arms, but for times when you don’t want to or indeed can’t then swaddling is an option. Swaddling is becoming increasingly popular, however there are important safety guidelines to be followed if you choose to swaddle your baby, if you are breastfeeding please make sure feeding is established before swaddling and take care not to miss your baby’s hunger cues if you are feeding on demand:
- Never swaddle over your baby’s head or near his face
- Never swaddle your baby if he is ill or has a fever
- Make sure your baby does not overheat and only swaddle with a breathable/thin fabric
- Only swaddle your baby until he can roll over**
- Always place your baby to sleep on his back
- Do not swaddle tightly across your baby’s chest
- Do not swaddle tightly around your baby’s hips and legs, his legs should be free to “froggy up” into a typical newborn position.
- Lastly start to swaddle as soon as possible, do not swaddle a 3 month old baby if he has not been swaddled before.
** The American Academy of Paediatrics recommends swaddling for babies 0-14wks.
Skin to Skin Contact
Such a brilliant baby calmer! Being in contact with your warm, naturally (un)scented, skin is heaven for a baby, it helps to stabilise their body temperature, heart rate and stress hormones and stimulates the release of oxytocin – the love and bonding hormone – in you both. Topless cuddles, shared baths, baby massage and bedsharing are all great skin to skin experiences for your baby and you.
Bed-Sharing
Sharing a bed with your baby is an amazing way of getting more sleep for everyone, babies are generally much calmer and sleep more easily if they sleep with you in your bed, yet it is such a taboo topic and although 60% of parents will share a bed with their baby at some point it’s a subject that makes society very uncomfortable, but…it is an *amazing* baby calmer! It’s really important that you think about how bedsharing will work and follow some important safety guidelines HERE.
Babywearing
Wearing your baby in a sling is one of the ultimate ways to keep them calm and happy. It increases the time a baby spends in a state of “quiet alertness” – a time of contentment when they learn the most. When a baby is in utero they spend 100% of their time in physical contact with us – yet the moment they are born this is estimated to drop to only 40%! Babywearing also means 2 free hands!
Choose your sling carefully. A good sling will be easy to use and will support both yours and your baby’s spine whilst not placing any pressure on your baby’s growing hips – newborns should always be carried facing inwards with a “frog leg” pose, not a crotch dangle pose so commonly used by commercial baby carriers. Also seek to carry in an ‘in arms’ position – i.e: how your baby would be held if you were holding them! This great picture from JePorteMonBebe highlights this newborn hold position perfectly.
Babywearing is a great way for dads to bond with babies!
It is quite common for a baby to cry once placed in a sling, this does not mean that they hate the sling – it just means that you need to move, so get dancing! As with swaddling,babywearing is becoming increasingly popular, however there are important safety guidelines to be followed, the TICKS acronym below neatly sums them all up:

Position
The “tiger in the tree” position below, taken from baby yoga, is often magical, stopping a crying baby in an instant!

Noise
Babies love sound, but for many not the sound you might think. For many babies a hoover is much more calming to a baby than a lullaby. A white noise CD such as the one by BabyCalm HERE can be played on loop whilst your baby sleeps to help keep them calm.
Feed
If your baby is hungry nothing will calm him, so watch for his hunger cues. Feeding is always better if it is baby led, not led by a routine – whether you are breast or bottle feeding. Remember as well that your baby may not always be hungry for a full feed, they may want a quick drink, a quick snack or just some comfort sucking. Babies also find sucking the ultimate relaxation and comfort tool. Sucking helps a baby’s skull bones to return to their normal position after birth as well as providing them with comfort and security. If you are not breastfeeding you might find your baby will relax when given a dummy/pacifier.
Deep Bathing
The womb is a wet, warm place. The world as we know it is dry and cold! Sometimes a nice deep, warm bath can stop a baby’s tears in seconds – even better if mummy or daddy goes in the big bath with baby too as skin to skin contact is a wonderful baby calmer.
Outside
If all else fails many babies stop crying the minute they hit the open air – I’m not sure if this is because we are usually moving (e.g.: walking over cobbles with the buggy/ bouncing in a sling and the drone and movement of a car) or because of the change in air – but it works!
If you like this article you’ll find many more suggestions and discussions on baby sleep, colic, babywearing, co-sleeping/bed-sharing and much more in my newly released BabyCalm Book – available from Amazon in the UK or with worldwide free delivery from The Book Depository if you live elsewhere in the world!
Written by:
Sarah (Mum to Four, Parenting Author and Founder of BabyCalm Ltd)
You can read more of Sarah’s articles HERE.
Trackbacks
- Friday finds 13/07/12 « Great British Family
- The Fourth Trimester – AKA: Why Your Newborn is Only Happy in Your Arms. « www.babycalm.co.uk | Milk & Magnolias
- The Decemberists! - Page 64 - BabyandBump
- Semester
- 2 Questions 1 Post - Page 2 - BabyandBump
- «Det fjerde trimester» – om hvorfor den nyfødte bare er tilfreds i dine armer | Lykkeligbarndom
- What is Baby Colic? « www.babycalm.co.uk
- The Fourth Trimester- aka Why Your Newborn is Only Happy in Your Arms « Jasmine Rose
- LO won't sleep for very long on her own what to do? - BabyandBump
- At my wits end :-( (Page 3) - Baby & Toddler Forum
- The Mamas’ Link Round-Up « Those Young Moms
- The Fourth Trimester – AKA: Why Your Newborn is Only Happy in Your Arms.
- HELP! I am FED up! - BabyandBump
- Anyone who has/had a newborn who doesn't sleep at night? - BabyandBump
- 6 week old baby wants to feed all night until about 10.30 - BabyandBump
- 4th trimester - BabyandBump
- 4th trimester - BabyandBump
- Bring on baby! Welcome! - Page 512 - BabyandBump
- The Fourth Trimester | tantriclemons
- Help baby wont sleep in Moses basket! - BabyandBump
- The Fourth Trimester | Mummiesbirthbuddy's Blog
- Where does you baby nap in the day
- My 6 week old cries until held! - Page 2 - BabyandBump
- Settling a newborn baby | Pram WalksPram Walks
- Baby Calm | Ripple Effect Yoga
- Open First Time Mom's - Due March/April 2013 - Page 183 - BabyandBump
- “Is she sleeping through the night yet?” | Nightclubs to Nightfeeds
- Clingy Newborn
- RAD and Other Attachment Disorders in Adoption and Foster Care - - Page 5 - City-Data Forum


.jpg)


Thank you for this post! So well written! Maria Montessori called the baby for the 9 months after birth, a spiritual embryo! So as fragile as an embryo, so needs great care unitl 9 months while he adjusts to the outside world!
Thanks for posting this, I am so glad to read something where the emphasis is on keeping baby happy rather than trying to force her into a routine. I love holding my baby in my arms whilst she’s settling and sleeping and am tired of people telling me I’m spoiling her. More people need to read articles like this and move away from thd old fashioned controlled crying approach, in my opinion :)
Wonderful, wonderful, wonderful! I’ll be sharing this resource with new mamas regularly!
Lovely! I held two babies for most of their infancies (despite frequent disapproval from others) and now enjoy the company of two confident, loving and creative children. I’ll definitely share this widely.
I held my boy sometimes. And sometimes I didn’t hold him. He is now confident, loving and creative. Had to know which approach worked. Maybe its another factor altogether??
Calming myself when I hold a baby. I know it isn’t always possible for the mother to be calm if her baby isn’t , and I’m not blaming the mother. It’s just that babies are very affected by the energy of the person who is holding them. If as the grown up I can calm myself it makes a big difference
Thank you so much everyone for the comments! To me everything here is common sense, I’m always amazed at the lengths we will go to to calm our babies with ‘apparatus’ and ‘gizmos’ – when all they really need are our arms! …but actually really I say that with hindsight, now after 4 babies and learning to ignore most of the baby raising advice in the mainstream books and media it’s common sense – as a new mum it was a revelation to me!
Sarahx
As i new mom i constantly googled every little and read dozens of books. While the whole time my mom would just tell more Follow your instinct songs do what feels right not what everyone tells you you should do. Best advice i ever got. My son co slept and spent the majority of the day in hisvMoby wrap. He is such a happy well adjusted baby
A sensitive, caring and supportive blog post, just wonderful. I’ll also be sharing this blog post!!
My “babies” are 34 and 31 now and as I read the blog, I wished I’d known these things back then. I was in the era of holding is spoiling. How I’d love to sit and hold my babies now, but time moves on and oh so quickly!
I’m not much of a mainstream person so I always went with what I thought my baby wanted. He was rarely out of the sling and loved being held in my arms whilst in the shower. I faced so much ridicule but everyone always told me I had the best, most content baby.
With baby wearing, try holding your baby supported by your arms for the first few times if they do not seem to like it much. That is the greatest piece of advice I have.
I think all of this is so wonderful, and in a perfect world most would agree they would love to spend their days holding their babies. There is no disputting that bonding with your baby in this manner is very important part of their development and thriving. However, I believe you forgot to mention that there are circumstances where holding your baby all day is impossible and these children grow up to be complete, loving, caring human beings as well and that their Mother’s have an equal amount of love for them. There are single Mom’s who must work, Mother’s of multiples, military Mom’s who are deployed serving their country and many other examples of devoted, loving Mother’s who are unable to hold and co-sleep with their babies. I am sure you thought of this, and hope I don’t come across as attacking your very well written and TRUE post, just wanted to add to this so that those Mother’s don’t feel guilty for their already stressful situations.
Our society is very harsh toward babies. It is much more oriented to selling things for babies and children than actually nurturing them.
I’m grateful for all those working to change our narratives and societal norms to put child-nurturing first for healthy, functioning societies. Starting with community support so that moms and dads can have much, much more time with their babies and children. As well as much better healthcare, school, and social systems.
I was thankful for my connection with LLL that supported my instinctive, unexpectedly strong inclination to hold and nurse my babies all the time. I was rather like a mother bear that way, and it surprised me because I was always such a people pleaser. Not when it came to what was best for my babies! However, it took a couple children for me to learn not to fall into the trap of visiting with company who came to see the newborn.
I wish I read this before I gave birth. I had to learn how to calm my baby through experience and it was a while before I understood that all she wanted was to be held.
I found that VISUAL stimulation was also calming. Baby would stop crying and stare at a vase of daffodils placed beside him, or pictures of a brightly colored butterfly or cartoon kids stuck on the wall near his face. He would look away and then look back, seeming to notice every detail–for quite a long time.
This is a fantastic and well written blog that encapsulates the the needs of a baby in the early days, weeks and months after birth. I didn’t really tap into this with my own children, although by my third I was getting there. It’s such a shame that I started to understand more after the events. However, I fully intend to sign post all expectant parents and new parents to this blog, as it should definately give them food for thought and a more balanced approach to responding to their baby’s needs or indeed strengthen their belief in responding to their child without fear of ‘spoiling’ or ‘making a rod for their own back’. Wouldn’t it be lovely if the NHS took on board this approach and this information was passed onto all parents ante natally!!!
The world would be a happier, healthier place if every mom-to-be read and used this information!
I believe that thousands–if not millions–of new mothers would want to spend their 4th trimester this way… IF they knew, and IF they had support to do so, and IF they figured it out before their babies were 20 years old : )
Isolated in nuclear families, feeling pressure to get back to work or a “normal” life, and bombarded with “direction” from commercial interests, women are often completely unaware of what should be natural and instinctual.
It’s for that reason that I wrote my book, NEW MOTHER: Using a Doula, Midwife, Postpartum Doula, Maid, Cook, or Nanny to Support Healing, Bonding, and Growth
As the other women who commented here, I will be sharing this concise, wonderful blog post!
I think this is lovely. My baby was considered “difficult” because she was only happy if I was holding her. I bought a sling and carried her for hours every day – I was comfy, she was comfy, she slept well and was otherwise calm. It was actually really nice for both of us. I still get a bit prickly when my mothering friends remind me of what a “difficult” baby she was!
Love this blog post, so many useful tips to help the newborn baby adjust to life outside the womb – I will be sharing this as well.
I absolutely love this. Thanku! Just re-affirming I am doing everything right :)
With my first baby, I spent so much time pacing the hallway and then repeatedly trying to lay him down for a nap and sneak away (the longest he ever stayed asleep this way was probably 15 min, AFTER I put him down!), with the 2nd we just carried/held and wore her and went about our business. She would sleep and wake as she wanted, and has always been such a happy little girl. And no stress on our end over trying to do what we were “supposed” to do! I think she was carried for naps through the first 9 months at least, and after that it depended on where we were (out and about or home so we could lay down with her). Love this article, as a parent you can waste so much time and energy trying to fit your practices into the mold of what others tell you is right, OR you can be mellow and parent naturally with the rhythm of your family (including baby’s rhythm!).
Excellent article! Exactly how we parent our wee ones!
I need my husband to read this! I am a big fan of holding my daughter and she let everyone know she wanted to be held, lay her down and she would cry, pick her up and she would instantly calm. Almost all babies want it, some are just more forceful about voicing their desire! I wish more people realized this instead of forcing babies to sleep alone in a different room, forced to “become independent” at a couple months old, and expect babies to behave like little adults. There would be a lot more connected and bonded families.
http://taurusmom18.wordpress.com/
I love this, thank you so much for sharing!
I find with my postpartum clients, their biggest worry is “creating a monster” who needs to be held all the time because that’s what their Mother-in-law warned them about. I always gently reassure them that this is what their baby needs right now, and that as they get used to the outside world they will be more interested in being on their own, without you having to do any “training”. They are always very relieved to hear this, so I try to spread the word as much as possible!
Thanks so much. I was worried I was spoiling him and that he was overeating.this helped a lot
Thanks again
I get this, I really do. But my 4-week-old screams just as much when I’m holding her, hates being swaddled and appears to hate skin to skin. :-( The sling is a godsend, but only if I manage to get her into it in one of the small windows before she starts yelling.
Hi Rosie, the important thing is she screams when you hold her, not screams alone. Have you visited a cranial osteopath/chiropractor? and a lactation consultant to check for tongue tie? It sounds as if something else might be happening.
I love that thin carrier in that picture… I tried to look it up to see if I could buy one, but I have been unable to locate it. Do you know who makes them or what it might be made of? I am a very warm person and my babies have both been too, looks ideal for us… ps great article … I am lucky to have been confident of listening to my instincts and my babies.
Hi there, I don’t think it’s for sale, just to demo a picture. The coolest carriers we’ve found are the Calin Bleu gauze http://www.babycalming.com/product/Calin-Bleu-Cool-Cotton-Gauze-Wrap or the F’il up http://www.babycalming.com/product/Fil'-Up-Mesh-Wrap-Sling HTH.
Hi, I don’t understand if with “4th trimester” you mean 1 year old babies? When yes, my baby is one year old and after some months of enjoying being independent and playing alone, is now again very attached and wants to be always in my arms. Which is very nice and normal, but also very tiring for me, as I don’t manage again to have a shower or things like these, as when she was born. Thank you!
Good stuff. You are validating the concerns so many parents have about “holding baby too much”. This is where they desire to be, and benefit from being. Cuddle ‘em while you can, cuz pretty soon it is running just to keep up!
I love this post! I remember after my first child was born, we were in the hospital and she was really upset around 3 AM. I was exhausted and getting frustrated because I couldn’t calm her, so I called for the nurse. At first I was a little weirded out because she took my daughter and told me to take my shirt off so I was just in my bra. I did, and she took my baby and put her on my chest and tucked us both in. It was like magic. Babies love that security (and I did too)! Thanks for the great post.
These are great ideas!
One thing that works for my baby when she is really tired is laying her in my arms, wrapping her blanket around her with a part of the blanket touching her cheek and slightly bouncing and swaying her.
This is craziness. You people are crazy. Absolutely bonkers. The only thing that I see coming from this is stressed out parents. Parents will grind themselves into the ground following this mentality. I guess that I might start world war three disagreeing with a bunch of sleep deprived parents but oh well.
I love the idea of holding my baby boy for his sleeps every day. I guess the only issue I have with this is how on earth do you get dinner ready for the rest of the family with a bub attached to your front??? Any suggestions most appreciated.
Thanks for the article – just one question, though: I have heard that white noise is being investigated as possibly causing autism. Apparently, noise should be kept to a minimum while a bub is sleeping, constant noise is supposed to affect their brain. Have you heard this?
* Apparently the book “the brain that changes itself” brings this up as well
Fantastic post. I spent weeks and weeks trying to find way to put my first baby down. During the day I let her fall asleep on me but at night thought she had to go in her basket. Think partly it was nerves – would I suffocate her/roll onto her/ would she fall out etc? But in the end her Dad and I used to take turns lying next to her until she slept. Now have my 4th baby and he sleeps in the bed with us – he’s 16 months old and so far has never spent a night away from me. He feeds a bit in the night but I have never had such good sleep – he is settled and dreamy, not wakeful. He moves himself to lie sprawled between us now, no longer needs to be in my arms all night. In his own time he’ll be ready to sleep happily. It’s taken me 4 children to trust my own instincts! This article is a very well written and reassuring take on the whole thing – WISH I’d had this from Number 1!
I was a mom at 18 I had no books or guru to help me calm my baby. What taught me is natural instinct. If anyone needs instructions on how to care for their baby we need to re evaluate our society. Babies are supposed to be held, and soothed by mommy or daddy not by a machine or a babysitter. Although I enjoyed reading this it brought some wonderful memories up, it made me chuckle at people’s lack of parenting abilities.
I have been reading your excellent book whilst in hospital with my newborn baby, she was only 3lb 9oz. You say don’t share a bed if baby was born with low birth weight, what do you recommend instead for the situations when you would normally revommend bed sharing?
I agree with everything written but I’d like to see Breastfeed as option one. Breastfeeding is so much more than nutrition. Baby is close to Mum’s heart and the smell of the breast (Montgomery glands are reminiscent of the amniotic fluid). Could you also mention the benefits of “Non Nutritive” sucking?
It’s so wonderful to know we did something right!! My oldest was a calm baby but for the first month he hated his back so he slept on my bare chest. (Pillows under my arms, securing him). My daughter loved the “tiger in tree” and when she cried taking a quick walk around the house calmed her right away! My last was a “water baby”. Turn on a tap or the shower and he calmed right down. He STILL prefers to sleep with Mommy (he’s 3! lol). My daughter was 6 when she finally slept through the night in her own bed (only because Mommy was too big with baby so she didn’t fit in our bed anymore. lol). I loved our family bed! It helped create a bond with my kids that I still have today (the oldest is 13!!). Great advice for old and new moms alike!
Oh! I also wore my last baby. I even figured out how to use the sling as a “back pack” for him once he was too big for the front. :D I recommend wraps for all moms!
Oh the nonsense I had from other mum’s/ relatives about holding my daughter while I ate my lunch, for taking her in the bath with me, for not smacking her, for bla bla bla… it was endless.
I was told she would never be toilet trained, she would never feed herself, she would never sleep alone, she would be uncontrollable . Why? because I responded to her needs and nurtured her, because I wouldn’t leave her to scream it out.
She’s a happy, intelligent and responsible eleven year old who not only feels she can talk to me about anything but also strangely manages all her hygiene needs herself, even though she shared a bath with me into toddlerdom. (I sometimes feel like reminding people of the judgements they passed about her!)
Mum knows best, no one can know a baby as well as their mum does. It’s that simple.